Issues with diagrams in 11-036r9

Stephen Finch Stephen.Finch at
Mon Jul 25 08:00:08 PDT 2011

Formatted message: <a href="">HTML-formatted message</a>

Figure 17, on page 46, shows the Train_Tx-SNW as being composed of RCDT and
MTTT before exiting to Train_RX-SNW.  There are two issues with this:
1.	  Figure 16 shows the Train_Tx-SNW.  It consists of RCDT followed by
MRTT.  In the case of Train_Tx-SNW exiting to Train_Rx-SNW, the RCDT does
not exist.  Therefore, technically, what the Train_Tx-SNW is going to is
only a part of the Train_Rx-SNW.
2.	 Figure 17 shows MTTT as occurring before the transition to
Train_Rx-SNW.  In fact, if MTTT is met, the transition will not be to
3.	 Figure 16 has the same issue for MRTT as in item 2.
I think the text in the state machines is what is intended.  It just that
one could misinterpret the diagrams.
Stephen Finch
720 864-4751
720 883-1414 (cell)
Western Digital, Longmont
This communication is for the exclusive use of the addressee and may contain
Western Digital confidential and/or non-disclosable information. Any
distribution, reading, copying or use of this communication by anyone other
than the addressee is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you have
received this message by mistake, please delete it immediately and advise
the sender you have done so by sending an E-Mail to Stephen Finch
<stephen.finch at  >

More information about the T10 mailing list