SAS 2.1r4 letter ballot comment resolution status

Alvin Cox alvin.cox at seagate.com
Mon Jul 12 22:22:52 PDT 2010


Formatted message: <a href="http://www.t10.org/cgi-bin/ac.pl?t=r&f=r1007130_f.htm">HTML-formatted message</a>

The report for the original responses;
Processing "sas21-r04.fdf"
acceptonly: author=LSI - George Penokie chapter= Chapter 0 page=15
acceptonly: author=Kevin_Marks chapter= Chapter 0 page=15
Unclassified: author=CoxA chapter= Chapter 0 page=30 comment=
Unclassified: author=LSI - George Penokie chapter= Chapter 5 page=186
comment=þÿ A C C E P T	 -   D O N E
 T i d l e  ÛÀÜ    1 7 5   n s
 T h e	 b o x	 n e e d s   t o   b e	 c h a n g e d	 t o   a   g r e a t
e r   t h a n	o r   e q u a l   c h a r a c t e r .
Unclassified: author=LSI - George Penokie chapter= Chapter 5 page=186
comment=þÿ A C C E P T	 -   D O N E
 T i d l e  ÛÀÜ    5 2 5   n s
 T h e	 b o x	 n e e d s   t o   b e	 c h a n g e d	 t o   a   g r e a t
e r   t h a n	o r   e q u a l   c h a r a c t e r .
Unclassified: author=LSI - George Penokie chapter= Chapter 5 page=186
comment=þÿ A C C E P T	 -   D O N E
 T i d l e  ÛÀÜ    1   5 7 5   n s
 T h e	 b o x	 n e e d s   t o   b e	 c h a n g e d	 t o   a   g r e a t
e r   t h a n	o r   e q u a l   c h a r a c t e r .
Author
			   Total comments:
			   |	Accept - Done:
			   |	|   Accept - Todo:
			   |	|   |	Accept - Last:
			   |	|   |	|   Accept (only):
			   |	|   |	|   |	Reject - Todo:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   Reject (only):
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	Refer PHY:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   Refer PROTOCOL:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	Total
worked:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   Left:
	     Chapter 0:  148  111   0	0   2	0  34	0   0  147   1
	     Chapter 1:    7	6   0	0   0	0   1	0   0	 7   0
	    Chapter 10:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	    Chapter 11:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	    Chapter 12:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	    Chapter 13:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	     Chapter 2:    4	4   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 4   0
	     Chapter 3:   99   85   0	0   0	0  14	0   0	99   0
	     Chapter 4:  361  299   0	0   0	0  62	0   0  361   0
	     Chapter 5:  144  109   0	0   0	0  32	0   0  141   3
	     Chapter 6:   24   21   0	0   0	0   3	0   0	24   0
	     Chapter 7:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	     Chapter 8:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	     Chapter 9:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
		 ButtK:    1	1   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 1   0
		  CoxA:   21   20   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	20   1
	   Kevin_Marks:  123   84   0	0   1	0  38	0   0  123   0
       LSI - Brian Day:   10	9   0	0   0	0   1	0   0	10   0
  LSI - George Penokie:  189  173   0	0   1	0  12	0   0  186   3
   LSI - Harvey Newman:   33   27   0	0   0	0   6	0   0	33   0
	    Mark Evans:    1	1   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 1   0
	      McGrathJ:    8	1   0	0   0	0   7	0   0	 8   0
	   OganessyanG:    1	1   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 1   0
	      RElliott:   88   52   0	0   0	0  36	0   0	88   0
	       SymonsT:    2	1   0	0   0	0   1	0   0	 2   0
       WDC, Mark Evans:  105   76   0	0   0	0  29	0   0  105   0
		 WittK:    1	1   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 1   0
	      relliott:  204  188   0	0   0	0  16	0   0  204   0
----------------
Total comments: 787
 Accept - Done: 635 (80.69%)
 Accept - Last: 0 (0.00%)
 Accept - Todo: 0 (0.00%)
 Accept (only): 2 (0.25%)   (Remove revision history before public review)
 Reject - Todo: 0 (0.00%)
 Reject (only): 146 (18.55%)
     Refer PHY: 0 (0.00%)
Refer PROTOCOL: 0 (0.00%)
  Total worked: 783 (99.49%)
	  Left: 4 (0.51%)     (some error in the program not allowing these
to register as ACCEPT - DONE)
Actual count is 100% worked.
George enokie provided a review for SAS 2.1r4b. Here are the results for
those comments:
Processing "sas21-r04b.fdf"
Author
			   Total comments:
			   |	Accept - Done:
			   |	|   Accept - Todo:
			   |	|   |	Accept - Last:
			   |	|   |	|   Accept (only):
			   |	|   |	|   |	Reject - Todo:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   Reject (only):
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	Refer PHY:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   Refer PROTOCOL:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	Total
worked:
			   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   |	|   Left:
	     Chapter 0:    6	6   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 6   0
	     Chapter 1:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	    Chapter 10:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	    Chapter 11:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	    Chapter 12:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	    Chapter 13:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	     Chapter 2:    2	2   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 2   0
	     Chapter 3:   12   12   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	12   0
	     Chapter 4:   53   53   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	53   0
	     Chapter 5:   57   57   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	57   0
	     Chapter 6:    3	3   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 3   0
	     Chapter 7:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	     Chapter 8:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
	     Chapter 9:    0	0   0	0   0	0   0	0   0	 0   0
  LSI - George Penokie:  133  133   0	0   0	0   0	0   0  133   0
----------------
Total comments: 133
 Accept - Done: 133 (100.00%)
 Accept - Last: 0 (0.00%)
 Accept - Todo: 0 (0.00%)
 Accept (only): 0 (0.00%)
 Reject - Todo: 0 (0.00%)
 Reject (only): 0 (0.00%)
     Refer PHY: 0 (0.00%)
Refer PROTOCOL: 0 (0.00%)
  Total worked: 133 (100.00%)
	  Left: 0 (0.00%)
-- 
Alvin Cox
Seagate Technology, LLC
Cell 405-206-4809
Office 405-392-3738
E-Mail	alvin.cox at seagate.com



More information about the T10 mailing list