Results of letter ballot on SES Amendment #1

[John Lohmeyer]

* From the T10 Reflector (t10 at t10.org), posted by:
* John Lohmeyer <lohmeyer at t10.org>
*
Voting Results on T10 Letter Ballot 00-018r0 on
Forwarding SES Amendment 1 Rev 00 to first public review

Organization                      Name                 S Vote Add'l Info
--------------------------------- -------------------- - ---- ----------
Adaptec, Inc.                     lawrence lamers      P Yes
AMP / Tyco Electronics            charles brill        P Yes
Amphenol Interconnect             Bill Mable           P Yes
Berg Electronics                  Douglas Wagner       P Yes
BREA Technologies, Inc.           Bill Galloway        P Yes
Brocade Communications            Robert Snively       P Yes
Circuit Assembly Corp.            Ian Morrell          P Yes
CMD Technology                    Edward Haske         P Yes
Compaq Computer Corp.             Robert Elliott       P Yes
Crossroads Systems, Inc.          Neil Wanamaker       P Yes
Dallas Semiconductor              Charles Tashbook     P Yes
Dell Computer                                            DNV
EMC                               gary s robinson      P Yes
ENDL                              Ralph Weber          A Yes  IV
Exabyte Corp.                     Michael Taylor       P Yes
Fujitsu                                                  DNV
General Dynamics                  Nathan Hastad        P Yes
Hewlett Packard Co.               Stewart Wyatt        P Yes
Hitachi Cable Manchester,Inc      Zane Daggett         P Yes
Honda Connectors                  Thomas J. Kulesza    P Yes
IBM Corp.                         George Penokie       P Yes
Iomega Corp.                      Tim Bradshaw         P Yes
KnowledgeTek, Inc.                Dennis P Moore       P Yes
LSI Logic Corp.                   John Lohmeyer        P Yes
Madison Cable Corp.               Jie Fan              P Yes
Maxtor Corp.                      Pete McLean          P Yes
Molex Inc.                        Joe Dambach          P Yes
NSTOR                                                    DNV
Ophidian Designs                  Edward A. Gardner    P Yes  IV
Panasonic Technologies, Inc       Han Zou              P Yes
Philips Electronics                                      DNV
QLogic Corp.                                             DNV
Quantum Corp.                     Mark S. Evans        P Yes
Seagate Technology                Gene Milligan        P No   IV Cmnts
Storage Technology Corp.                                 DNV
Sun Microsystems, Inc.            kenneth Moe          P Yes
Texas Instruments                 Paul D. Aloisi       P Yes
Toshiba America Elec. Comp.       Tasuku Kasebayashi   P Yes
Woven Electronics                 Doug Piper           P Yes

Key:
P       Voter indicated he/she is principal member
A       Voter indicated he/she is alternate member
O       Voter indicated he/she is observer member
?       Voter indicated he/she is not member or does not know status
YesC    Yes with comments vote
Abs     Abstain vote
DNV     Organization did not vote
IV      Individual vote (not organizational vote)
Cmnts   Comments were included with ballot
NoCmnts No comments were included with a vote that requires comments
DUP     Duplicate ballot (last ballot received from org. is counted)
PSWD    The password was not correct (vote not counted)
ORG?    Organization is not voting member of T10 (vote not counted)

Ballot totals:
  32 Yes
   1 No
   0 Abstain
   6 Organization(s) did not vote
  39 Total voting organizations
   1 Ballot(s) included comments

This 2/3rds majority ballot passed.
32 Yes is at least a majority of the membership [20] AND
32 Yes is at least 22 (2/3rds of those voting, excluding abstentions [33])

**************************************************************

Comments attached to No ballot from Gene Milligan of
Seagate Technology:

Acrobat has chose to summarize the notes in a different order than was
intended. Please do not be disturbed by the order.

Notes from sesar00.pdf
Page 1
Note 1; Label: Seagate Employee; Date: 6/30/0 3:09:18 PM
<<in Table A.2 "Configuration page, using sub-enclosure identifiers," change
the "Bytes" column entry for the First sub-enclosure descriptor PRODUCT
REVISION LABEL from "(8 bytes)" to "(4 bytes)">>

    This change is either wrong or missleading. Change it to "in Table A.2
"Configuration page, using sub-enclosure identifiers," change the "Bytes"
column entry for the First sub-enclosure descriptor PRODUCT REVISION LABEL
|from "44-47" to "44-51".

Note 2; Label: Seagate Employee; Date: 6/30/0 2:59:51 PM
<<in Table 18 "Format of OVERALL DESCRIPTOR and ELEMENT DESCRIPTOR," swap
"LSB" and "MSB" for bytes 2 and 3 (DESCRIPTOR LENGTH) so "MSB" is in byte 2
and "LSB" is in byte 3.>>

This change is either wrong or incomplete depending upon your view. Change the

description in Table 18, Format of OVERALL DESCRIPTOR and ELEMENT DESCRIPTOR,
of the DESCRIPTOR LENGTH field such that byte 2, bit 7 is "(MSB)" and byte 3,
bit 0 is "LSB". Even better would be a replacement table.

Note 3; Label: Seagate Employee; Date: 6/30/0 3:23:46 PM
Also change <<and change the entry for VENDOR SPECIFIC ENCLOSURE INFORMATION
|from "(p - 40 bytes)" to "(p - 36 bytes).">> to "and change the entry for
VENDOR SPECIFIC ENCLOSURE INFORMATION from "48-(m+11)" to "52-(m+11)".

Note 4; Label: Seagate Employee; Date: 6/30/0 3:28:12 PM
In addition Table A.2 in the Byte column seems to use an arbitrary mixture of
the Byte Number and the number of bytes. This seems to add to the confusion.
Again a replacement table would be even better.




******************** End of Ballot Report ********************

--
John Lohmeyer                  Email: lohmeyer at t10.org
LSI Logic Corp.                Voice: +1-719-533-7560
4420 ArrowsWest Dr.              Fax: +1-719-533-7183
Colo Spgs, CO 80907

*
* For T10 Reflector information, send a message with
* 'info t10' (no quotes) in the message body to majordomo at t10.org