SMC-2000 Meeting Minutes (attendee review)
Skip Jones
sk_jones at qlc.com
Mon Oct 23 14:49:37 PDT 1995
Larry and Reflector-ites,
I urge all of you to refer to these activities for the time being as the "SCSI
Marketing Group", as we have NOT decided on a name yet. Until we have decided
on a name, carelessly trowing around names such as calling this SCSI-2000 have
an unfortunate way of sticking. Then when we go to change it, all we really
did was confuse people again.
I strongly believe that the last thing we need to do in parallel SCSI is
confuse the market any further. Shame on us! We are supposed to be a
marketing group so we above all have NO excuse for confusing the market.
While on the subject, Marketing-101 highlights the danger of of embracing names
of anykind which "date" the product (organization). While I understand how
people can get caught-up in zowie, whiz-bang, neato names, please take off the
engineering hat long enough to look at this objectively. SCSI-2000 IMMEDIATELY
dates parallel SCSI to a 5 year product at best and leaves the impression that
2000 is the end. I do not believe that is the message that we are trying to
convey. While 2000 may seem like a long enough ways away, it in fact
terminates the perception of migration far too early for what 'should' be our
motivation. 2000 is only four years away. Pretty weak migration strategy,
huh?
Skip Jones,
QLogic Marketing Manager
_______________________________________________________________________________
From: LJLamers at corp.adaptec.com on Fri, Oct 20, 1995 9:26 AM
Subject: SMC-2000 Meeting Minutes (attendee review)
To: 71202.740 at compuserve.com; Aloisi at uicc.com; bill.gintz at conner.com;
brian_davis at notes.seagate.com; crctassmbl at aol.com; dave.guss at tus.ssi1.com;
debbie_gurkowski at maxtor.com; dfields at corp.adaptec.com; dougherty_p at a1.wdc.com;
farhat at rockie.nsm.com; fhaq at asic.qntm.com; grantham at dalsemi.com;
hagerman at starch.enet.dec.com; ham at subsys.enet.dec.com; harry.mason at symbios.com;
haynes_dennis at bbrown.com; JMCGRATH at QNTM.COM; john.lohmeyer at symbios.com;
jschimdt at corp.adaptec.com; kelly.bryant at symbios.com; ljlamers at aol.com;
marc_lowe at corp.adaptec.com; massiglia at general.enet.dec.com;
mchenery at fcpa.fujitsu.com; mevans at QNTM.COM; mike.fitzpatrick at notes.seagate.com;
mike_robinson at notes.seagate.com; miked at buslogic.com; mkane at corp.adaptec.com;
n_cheng at hitachi.com; nharris at eng.adaptec.com; sk_jones at qlc.com;
theodore at vnet.ibm.com; tobias_pete at tandem.com
Minutes of SCSI-2000 Marketing Meeting : October 16,1995
Doc: SMAMINr0.DOC Date: 10/20/95
Reply to: Lawrence J. Lamers
To: SCSI-2000 Marketing Association Membership
From: Lawrence J. Lamers
Subject: Minutes of SCSI-2000 Marketing Meeting : October 16,1995
Agenda
1. Opening Remarks
2. Attendance and Introductions
3. Approval of Agenda
4. Approval of Minutes
5. Document Distribution
6. Review of Old Action Items
7. Goals
7.1 Parallel SCSI Marketing [McGrath]
7.2 SCSI Futures [Hagerman]
7.3 SCSI Futures [Mason]
7.4 Postmortem on Fast-20 []
7.5 Segmentation []
8. Recommendations
9. Futures
9.1 Parallel SCSI Marketing Association [McGrath]
10. Action Items
11. Meeting Schedule
12. Adjournment
1. Opening Remarks
Jim McGrath convened the meeting at 9:30 am. The meeting was hosted by
Quantum.
The minutes of this meeting will be posted to the SCSI BBS and the SCSI
Reflector.
Jim stated that the focus of this meeting is to provide marketing guidance
to the technical community. There is a separate set of meetings conducted
as adhoc meetings of X3T10 that are dealing with the technical issues.
2. Attendance and Introductions
The attendees introduced themselves.
The following people attended the meeting.
Name Organization Electronic Mail Address
---------------------- -------------------------
-------------------------Mr. Mitch Kane Adaptec
mkane at corp.adaptec.com
Mr. Mark Lowe Adaptec marc_lowe at corp.adaptec.com
Mr. Jim Schmidt Adaptec jschimdt at corp.adaptec.com
Mr. Douglas Fields Adaptec, Inc. dfields at corp.adaptec.com
Mr. Norm Harris Adaptec, Inc. nharris at eng.adaptec.com
Mr. Lawrence J. Lamers Adaptec, Inc. ljlamers at aol.com
Mr. Dennis R. Haynes Burr-Brown Corp. haynes_dennis at bbrown.com
Mr. Mike Dreitlein BusLogic miked at buslogic.com
Mr. Dennis Lang Circuit Assembly Corp. crctassmbl at aol.com
Mr. Ian Morrell Circuit Assembly Corp. crctassmbl at aol.com
Mr. William C. Gintz Conner Peripherals bill.gintz at conner.com
Mr. Louis Grantham Dallas Semiconductor grantham at dalsemi.com
Mr. Douglas Hagerman Digital Equipment Corp.
hagerman at starch.enet.dec.com
Dr. William Ham Digital Equipment Corp. ham at subsys.enet.dec.com
Mr. Paul Massiglia Digital Equipment Corp.
massiglia at general.enet.dec.com
Mr. Mike Chennery Fujitsu mchenery at fcpa.fujitsu.com
Ms. Nancy Cheng Hitachi Computer Products n_cheng at hitachi.com
Mr. Theodore Deffenbaugh IBM Corp. theodore at vnet.ibm.com
Ms. Debbi Gurkowski Maxtor debbie_gurkowski at maxtor.com
Mr. Afif Farhat National Semiconductor farhat at rockie.nsm.com
Mr. Skip Jones QLogic Corp. sk_jones at qlc.com
Mr. Mark Evans Quantum Corp. mevans at qntm.com
Mr. Faisal Haq Quantum Corp. fhaq at asic.qntm.com
Mr. James McGrath Quantum Corp. JMCGRATH at QNTM.COM
Mr. Brian N. Davis Seagate Technology brian_davis at notes.seagate.com
Mr. Mike Fitzpatrick Seagate Technology
mike.fitzpatrick at notes.seagate.com
Mr. Michael Robinson Seagate Technology
mike_robinson at notes.seagate.com
Mr. Hank Meyer Self 71202.740 at compuserve.com
Mr. Dave Guss Silicon Systems dave.guss at tus.ssi1.com
Mr. Kelly Bryant Symbios Logic Inc. kelly.bryant at symbios.com
Mr. John Lohmeyer Symbios Logic Inc. john.lohmeyer at symbios.com
Mr. Harry Mason Symbios Logic Inc. harry.mason at symbios.com
Mr. Pete Tobias Tandem Computers tobias_pete at tandem.com
Mr. Brett Philip Temp-Flex Cable Inc. Fax: 408-739-1237
Mr. Paul D. Aloisi Unitrode Aloisi at uicc.com
Mr. Peter Dougherty Western Digital dougherty_p at a1.wdc.com
36 People Present
3. Approval of Agenda
The agenda was developed as the meeting progressed.
4. Approval of Minutes
None.
5. Document Distribution
Parallel SCSI Marketing - Jim McGrath, Quantum
SCSI Futures - Doug Hagerman, DEC.
6. Review of Old Action Items
None.
7. Goals
7.1. Parallel SCSI Marketing [McGrath]
Jim McGrath made a brief presentation introducing the topics.
Jim McGrath presented the following list of issues/topics that he felt
should be prioritized for technical work:
Transfer Rates
Signaling Technology
Hybrid
Cable Length vs. Device Count [Mason]
CD-ROM Problem [McGrath]
Connectors
Greater than 16 devices
Bus extenders/bridges
50-ohm backplane problem
Fairness
Isochronous []
Wider buses
Doug Hagerman agreed with the above list and added:
SCSI Overhead
Paul Aloisi noted that the work on Enhanced Parallel Interface that plans
to issue a technical report already is addressing some of these items.
7.2. SCSI Futures [Hagerman]
Doug made a presentation on parallel SCSI. Parallel SCSI is the installed
base; the customer (i.e., end-user) uses parallel SCSI and plans to continue
to do so; there is a lot of hype around the serial interfaces; serial needs
maturity for consideration in enterprise systems.
There is a need for a vision for the future of parallel SCSI. A name is
needed to get folks to cheer for; Doug proposed SCSI-2000.
7.3. SCSI Futures [Mason]
There is a need for some organization to promote parallel SCSI; aid
customers and end-users in understanding features and capabilities given the
proliferation.
The next version needs strong positioning that is consistent.
7.4. Postmortem on Fast-20 []
Norm Harris requested a postmortem on the plusses and minuses of the Fast-20
effort. Jim McGrath noted that the naming was an issue that caused
confusion; the result was engineering driven to a set of perfomance goals
and did not consider all the market needs.
It was suggested that this group adopt some labels to clean up the
wide/narrow/Ultra/Fast-20 issues that are confusing users.
7.5. Segmentation []
Theodore Deffenbaugh felt that the marketing group should focus more on
marketing issues; in particular, identifying market segments as opposed to
dealing with technical and sales issues. Jim McGrath suggested that the
market segments should be: Server and PC/Work Station
Jim McGrath's opinion on market segment:
Assume server market, OEM sales, new systems
Competition is SSA and FC-AL.
Incumbant is SCSI-SE and SCSI-DIFF.
EIDE is not the competition in the server market.
The needs of the workstation market has be to factored into the decisions.
The workstation market does need an effective solution to the non-disk drive
attachments.
Mike Dreitlien suggested that what is needed is a performance roadmap for
parallel SCSI that preserves as much of the current investment as possible.
8. Recommendations
The consensus of this group was to address the restrictions incumbent with
Fast-20 regarding number of devices and cable length. These issues arise
mainly in the server environment.
Regarding documents the recommendation was to do LVDS + SE at Fast-20 and
LVDS at Fast-40 imediately.
The second tier issues that should be considered are backplane/cable
impedance mismatch, CD-ROM problem, autotermination, fairness, and
isochronous are intermediate. All others are long term.
9. Futures
9.1. Parallel SCSI Marketing Association [McGrath]
Jim McGrath took a straw poll on forming an association for marketing
parallel SCSI. All folks present were in favor of a marketing group; and
all indicated that their company would be willing to join such an
association.
DEC, IBM, Symbios, Seagate, Quantum, Unitrode, Dallas Semiconductor, Qlogic
and Adaptec volunteered to work on forming an organization.
Mike Fitzpatrick stated that a Marketing Association could benefit parallal
SCSI. The group supported this. A mission statement is needed. ENDL is a
possible facilitator.
SCSI-2000 Mission Statement
To evangelize the benefits of SCSI as a flexible, powerful peripheral
interconnect for server and desktop computing and to influence the direction
of future SCSI developments to maintain it's superiority through the year
2000.
Objectives
Promote increased usage of parallel SCSI
Educate customers on when to use SCSI Reduce confusion concerning SCSI
Provide focal point for press, industry, and customer communications
regarding SCSI
Advance and promote product interoperability
Advance and promote storage as a focal point for system differentiation
Shape the evolution of SCSI technology
Evangelize SCSI as a flexible and powerful connectivity solution foir many
applications
Orchestrate a convergence on a common interconnect
Specific tasks
Joint marketing/ industry marketing programs
Generate a press release on SCSI-2000 Marketing Association
Establish a naming convention for speed/bus width
Communicate SCSI futures roadmap to press/public Set up a Reflector
Set up an 800 number
Set up a web site
Set up a ftp site
Set up a faxback service
Trade show
Publications
Training
Provide guidance to technical committees
10. Action Items
1) John Lohmeyer to talk to Dal Allan regarding setting up association
2) Paul Massiglia and JIm McGrath to set up next meeting 12/14/95
3) Mike Fitzpatrick to distribute FCLC bylaws.
4) Larry Lamers and Mark Lowe to develop mission statement and charter.
5) Name for group; technology naming system; commitment to pay; finalize
mission statement; agree to by-laws; if so what and when list.
11. Meeting Schedule
The next meeting is planned for December 14, 1995 in San Jose, CA. Details
to follow on the SCSI reflector.
12. Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 3:00 p.m. on Monday.
More information about the T10
mailing list