I'm easy...rip it out   8-)
 
While you're at it, rip out the line above ("PRLI Common Service Parareters"). You already moved it into table 34, which I think we agreed at the last meeting.
 
   - bob

From: David Peterson [mailto:dpeterso@Brocade.COM]
Sent: Thursday, April 10, 2008 8:32 AM
To: Nixon, Bob; t11_3@t11.org; t10@t10.org
Subject: RE: [T11.3] FC-DA-2: table 35 - ACC Response code = "Command executed"

Howdy Bob,

 

I disagree with stating the obvious. The row is misleading and again provides no value.

 

FCP already states: An accept response code indicating other than REQUEST EXECUTED (see 6.3.5 and FC-LS) shall be provided if the PRLI ELS FCP Service Parameter page is incorrect or if a requested image pair is not established.

 

…Dave

 

From: Bob.Nixon@Emulex.Com [mailto:Bob.Nixon@Emulex.Com]
Sent: Wednesday, April 09, 2008 5:11 PM
To: David Peterson; t11_3@t11.org; t10@t10.org
Subject: RE: [T11.3] FC-DA-2: table 35 - ACC Response code = "Command executed"

 

Hi, Dave, I think what that row is trying to say is that a Target has to be able to give that response (if it couldn't, it could not be a Target). Other responses are not sepcifically prohibited by that line, although it could be read that way. I would suggest adding another row:

 

ACC Response code != “Command executed”:   -     A     P    -

 

 

   - bob

 

From: t11_3-bounces@listserve.com [mailto:t11_3-bounces@listserve.com] On Behalf Of David Peterson
Sent: Wednesday, April 09, 2008 11:49 AM
To: t11_3@t11.org; t10@t10.org
Subject: [T11.3] FC-DA-2: table 35 - ACC Response code = "Command executed"

FC-DA-2 table 35 has a row specifying an ACC Response code = “Command executed” is a Required PRLI response from an FCP target.

 

Other responses are certainly possible (see FCP-4) thus I believe this is wrong (and actually mislabeled) and provides no real value either.

 

I propose that the row be removed.

 

Comments?

 

...Dave